Lies of P has three different endings based on the choices you make in the game.
You can choose various Lie and Truth options throughout the game.
Furthermore, there is no need to choose only Truths or only Lies.
Here, we will discuss the details of the give heart option on the endings of Lies of P.
Table of Contents Show
The Endings Of Lies Of P
Lies of P has three different endings to the game, which are decided through your choices.
The three endings to the game are the true, good and bad endings.
This is quite common for soulslike games to have multiple endings.
Here is a breakdown of all the three endings of the game.
Ending 1: They Lived Happily Ever After
The “They Lived Happily Ever After” is the Real Boy ending. This ending is the worst possible ending for Lies of P.
Furthermore, this ending heavily affects your character and those around you.
You will find Geppetto after defeating Simon Manus and using the elevator.
Additionally, Geppetto will congratulate you and make you a real boy. You must give him your heart to become a real boy.
Therefore, you have a choice to make either Give Heart or Refuse.
Ending 2: Rise of P
Rise of P is another conclusion you can get to the game, which is a true ending.
To get the ending, the player must lie whenever possible and increase their humanity.
If you get the “Your Heart is Pounding” message, you are on the right path to this ending.
Additionally, you must follow the same path as the Real Boy ending to get to this ending.
Geppetto will give you the same two choices: give your heart or refuse.
Ending 3: Free From The Puppet String
Free From The Puppet String is the final ending you can gain to Lies of P.
This is a normal ending to the game; to get it, the player must tell the truth whenever possible.
Additionally, defeat Laxasia the Complete and interact with Sophia.
To further gain this ending, choose the option of “Let her live” to Sophia.
You will also have the option to either give your heart or refuse in this ending.
Give Heart Option In The Endings
The Give Heart option is available in all three endings of the game.
Accepting to give your heart or refusing is also an option that decides the game’s ending.
In addition, you have to choose the Give Heart option to get the Real Boy ending.
However, to get the Rise of P ending and Free From The Puppet String ending, you have to refuse to give your heart.
The consequences of the options are:
1. Give Heart Option
The Give Heart option activates the Real Boy ending of the game.
If you decide to choose this option, Geppetto will be very happy and satisfied with you.
In addition, he will take your heart and give it to his son to bring him back alive.
Finally, his family will be complete, and this will be a happy ending to the game.
2. Refusing To Give Your Heart
If you refuse to give your heart to Geppetto, he will be disappointed in you.
At first, he will be in denial, but he accepts after a while.
Then, accepting his fate and unable to bring his son, he will try to fight for your heart.
Furthermore, he will bring his son back to life for one last fight.
You must defeat the Nameless Puppet once you refuse to give your heart.
Geppetto will come between the fight to protect Carlo’s heart that you have.
Therefore, he will die from the attack of the Nameless Puppet.
He dies in regret, and choosing this option will make his wish to bring his son back to life will be unfulfilled.
The Bottom Line
Your choice of whether you give your heart or refuse also determines the game’s ending.
If you decide to give your heart, Geppetto will be thankful, and he will be able to revive his son back to life.
However, if you decide to refuse, Geppetto will be disappointed in you, and you will have to defeat the Nameless puppet.
